Learning from Failure

 


This is actually what happened in my classroom.

Me: “Who can solve this problem?”
Those who raised their hands…..3 out of 22

Me: “Ok, let’s put it this way. You can be uncertain, you can be wrong, but who have any tiny idea on this question?”
Those who raised their hands…..22 out of 22

Those who raise their hands when they are certain about the answer,
those who don’t raise their hands because they are uncertain about it.
The key of learning seems to lie in the latter.

[3 conditions of promoting learning in this situation]
・trying to express even when it’s uncertain
・Not feel ashamed when making mistakes
・Trying to learn from the mistakes

Today, in relation to this, I will talk about the article on Health project (NY times)
It’s called “learning from failure”

[Summary]
Health program which had worked in rural area in Bolivia, Nepal and India, had failed in Mumbai, urban area of India.

[Why failed]
・ the community-based program didn’t work in the urban area(e.g., in the city slums of Mumbai, mothers were hesitant to depend on neighbors who live a block away)
・ It’s harder to measure in urban area than in rural area.
・ Much of the global health boom since the 1990s has focused on rural areas; far less work has been done on urban programs in part the situation is difficult to manage.

[Approaches after the failure]
In order to succeed in the future, researchers admitted their failure by submitting detailed report – “I failed report.” The problem here, however, is not about the failure. It’s about other policy makers’ attitude toward the future.
The risk is that too few people will follow, because they have to deal with “what will be working then” strategy. Instead, they tend to work on success-based program even though it does not meet the relevancy as if they bury failures.
Obama’s new focus on aid community also pressure organizations for positive results
, which unable them to take a risk.
Of course evidence-based project is important to look at, but we also need the attitude to explore for the future which will change over the time.
What’s important is trying to admit the mistakes and try to do better next time.
First we need to accept the fact we can make a mistake (of course, classrooms and projects have different scales).

Link of the article:http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/03/opinion/sunday/learning-from-research-failure.html?_r=0

“You can be uncertain, you can be wrong, but who have any tiny idea on this question?”
I suppose we might need this kind of attitude.
I don’t think it would promote learning if you raise your hand only when you are certain about the answer. It might be the scoiety that creates this environment.

I always try to say and question things even if I make errors.
Since there are many things that I don’t know, I make a lot fo mistakes. Then I learn.
Failure/ mistake=>correction=> effort to fix


4 thoughts on “Learning from Failure

  1. MH

    SECRET: 0
    PASS:
    仰る通りだと思います。
    学校では、間違った答えを言って当たり前だと思うのです。正しい答えを知っているなら、学校へ行く必要ないですよね。
    まぁ、日本人は体裁を大いに気にする人種なので、その辺りも手を挙げない理由の一つなのかも。 

    Reply
  2. Keiko

    SECRET: 0
    PASS:
    このストーリー、気づきやすいようで実は気づけていない部分で、すごく面白かったです!学校は失敗して学ぶところであり、失敗を恐れず挑戦していくところだと思うので、子ども達が失敗を恐れずにどんどん挑戦することが出来るよう、教師や親側も、間違ってもうまくフォローできるようにならないとですね。

    Reply
  3. breakthewall1205

    SECRET: 0
    PASS:
    MHさん
    日本の教育現場だと、特にそういうところが強いかもしれませんね。それが謙虚さという長所に表れているのもあるかもしれませんが、時には大胆にリスクを背負うのが大事かなと、最近思います。国際社会で日本人がほとんど発言しないというのも前からある問題ですしね。言語の問題と言う人もいるかもしれませんが、前に出る気持ちさえあればブロークンでも頑張っている人もいますしね。

    Reply
  4. breakthewall1205

    SECRET: 0
    PASS:
    KEIKOさん
    「失敗を恐れないでいいよ」という環境は、子どもにもよりますが、なにより周り(学校・親・教師・地域)の努力が大事だと、自分も思います。わざと教師が間違える、なんてことも結構します。(たまに本当に間違えますが笑)

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *